📍 Ever dreamed of owning a fairytail cottage on a private island?
Now’s your chance.

Escape to your own private island paradise on The St Joseph River in Buchanan, Michigan! This unique and secluded property offers the perfect blend of natural beauty, recreation, and comfortable living.

Accessible only by boat, this private island offers unmatched tranquility, stunning water views, and a deep connection to nature. Surrounded by the serene waters of the St Joseph River, the island features towering trees, winding paths, and a handful of carefully situated homes that preserve the peaceful ambiance.

14931 Bachelors Island is part of a small community of island homes with a strong sense of stewardship and appreciation for this one-of-a-kind location. Whether you're sipping morning coffee on your porch, swimming in the clear water, or enjoying evening bonfires under the stars, this island life is about unplugging and reconnecting—with nature, loved ones, and yourself.

Spend your days fishing, kayaking, reading, jet skiing or floating in the sunshine, and your nights enjoying the calm and privacy that only an island can provide. If you're searching for a getaway unlike any other, where every visit feels like an adventure and every sunset reminds you of how beautiful life can be—this is the place.

• Tucked into the flowing beauty of the St. Joseph River, this rare island retreat in Buchanan, MI, is only accessible by boat—and it's worth every second of the ride. Whether you're casting a line from your private dock, enjoying a sunset bonfire, or cruising the river on a jet ski, this property delivers the kind of peace and adventure that can’t be found on the mainland.
  

Take a tour through the cottage and property at 14931 Bachelor Island near Buchanon MI

More about the Storybook Cottage

Escape to your own private island paradise on The St Joseph River in Buchanan, Michigan! This unique and secluded property offers the perfect blend of natural beauty, recreation, and comfortable living.

Accessible only by a 10 minute boat ride from the location where you park your car, this private island offers unmatched tranquility, stunning water views, and a deep connection to nature. Surrounded by the serene waters of the St Joseph RIver, the island features towering trees, winding paths, and a handful of carefully situated homes that preserve the peaceful ambiance. Association access area includes organized docking and boat parking support for island owners.

14931 Bachelors Island is part of a small community of island homes with a strong sense of stewardship and appreciation for this one-of-a-kind location. Whether you're sipping morning coffee on your porch, swimming in the clear water, or enjoying evening bonfires under the stars, this island life is about unplugging and reconnecting—with nature, loved ones, and yourself.

Spend your days fishing, kayaking, reading, paddle boarding, jet skiing or floating in the sunshine, and your nights enjoying the calm and privacy that only an island can provide. If you're searching for a getaway unlike any other, where every visit feels like an adventure and every sunset reminds you of how beautiful life can be—this is the place.

This is an actual view from the screened in porch. WOW….Imagine you could enjoy this as soon as you close on the property!

Completely turnkey opportunity — cottage comes furnished and ready to enjoy from day one. The purchase includes furnishings, kitchen supplies, bedding, linens, TV, outdoor furniture, and much of what is needed to immediately begin enjoying river life.

• Pontoon boat shown at the property is available for purchase separately from the cottage.

• 2-bedroom cottage layout with comfortable sleeping and gathering spaces for weekend retreats or extended stays. (Primary bedroom sleeps 2, 2nd bedroom sleeps 4, day bed in the living room sleeps 1)

• 1 bathroom with shower designed for practical cottage living and, if you are the adventurous type, there is an outdoor shower and rustic sauna!

• Around 400 feet of private St. Joseph River frontage creates expansive water views and exceptional privacy.

• Large private dock provides direct access for boating, fishing, swimming, kayaking, and relaxing at the water’s edge.

• Massive screened porch overlooking the river creates an ideal indoor/outdoor living and entertaining space. You will find yourself mesmerized by the river and totally comfortable relaxing with the sounds of nature.

• Vaulted ceilings and multiple outdoor gathering areas make the cottage feel open, airy, and larger than expected.

• Private pontoon boat access to the island immediately creates a unique “vacation mode” experience for owners and guests.

• All-sports river access supports pontoons, fishing boats, kayaks, paddleboards, and recreational boating.

• Updated mechanicals and utility improvements help provide peace of mind for future owners.

• Property reportedly remained resilient through major historic flooding events, adding confidence regarding the location and structure. The current owners have never needed to carry flood insurance.

• Private island cottage lifestyle on the St. Joseph River creates a true getaway atmosphere that is difficult to replicate.

• The setting offers exceptional peace and privacy — owners often describe feeling emotionally “removed” from everyday stress once they arrive.

• Evening bonfires, river sunsets, coffee on the porch, fishing from the dock, and slow mornings become part of everyday life here.

• Outdoor spaces are designed for entertaining friends and family with multiple gathering areas along the riverfront.

• The island community itself adds to the charm — buyers feel like they are “away” while still being within Southwest Michigan.

• Excellent second-home opportunity for buyers wanting a manageable escape from Chicago, Kalamazoo, or other Midwest cities.

What’s the area like around 14931 Bachelor Island, Buchanan, MI 49107

• Located near Buchanan, Michigan — named the “Nicest Town in America” by Reader’s Digest in 2020.
  Easy access to Southwest Michigan wineries, breweries, golf courses, beaches, farmers markets, and charming small-town dining.

• Approximately 35 minutes from the beaches of St. Joseph and New Buffalo.

• Near Orchard Hills Country Club and Brookwood Golf Course for additional recreation and entertainment.

• Convenient access to RedBud Motocross, one of the nation’s most recognized motocross destinations.

• The St. Joseph River offers miles of boating, fishing, kayaking, pontoon cruising, and waterfront exploration.

• Excellent fishing opportunities including largemouth bass, smallmouth bass, walleye, bluegill, crappie, salmon, and steelhead trout.

• Calm stretches of river nearby create an ideal environment for relaxing pontoon rides and peaceful waterfront living.

• Wildlife sightings are common throughout the area, contributing to the peaceful natural atmosphere.

• Southwest Michigan’s blend of beaches, wineries, boating, and small-town charm makes the area a highly desirable second-home destination.

• Convenient location for weekend getaways from Chicago, Northern Indiana, Kalamazoo, and throughout Southwest Michigan.

• The area offers a unique combination of outdoor recreation, relaxed pace of life, and easy access to entertainment and dining.

Meet Jason Veenstra of the Veenstra Team. We would love to bring you to experience this island cottage!

Ready to experience private island living? 🏝️ Showings for pre-qualified buyers are currently being scheduled through the Veenstra Team REALTORS for June 5th and 6th (earlier visits may be arranged as schedules allow).

Fill out the form below to start your adventure and book your private tour!

Frequently Asked Questions

• How do I schedule an appointment? Schedule an appointment by completing the form below, and we will be in touch to plan your visit. Because of the unique nature of this property—which requires a pontoon ride to access—we cannot simply provide generic showing instructions. That is part of the fun and adventure!

• How do I get pre-qualified? We have a list of preferred lenders you can choose from. There is no cost or obligation, and you will gain clarity about your financing options given your specific situation. Complete the form below to get the lender list.

• What if I am a cash buyer? If you are a cash buyer, you will need to show proof of funds. We have a list of items that qualify as proof of funds—just complete the form below to receive it.

• What if I am not sure how I will purchase yet? Talk to a lender to get clarity and a pre-qualification letter. This will allow you to make specific, informed decisions when you are ready to write an offer and will allow you to qualify for a visit to the island paradise.

• How can I write an offer on the property? Connect with the Veenstra Team, and they can explain your options. If you are already under contract with a buyer's agent, please have your agent contact the Veenstra Team directly.

• Where will I park my car? The Veenstra Team will share the location of the car park, which is run by the Island Association, when you call them to confirm your visit.

• Do I need to pay for the pontoon ride? No! The pontoon ride is not a shuttle service. We send a privately owned pontoon to the parking lot/dock area to pick you up at your appointed time. It is a gorgeous, complimentary 10-minute ride on the water to arrive at the cottage.